AP DSC Special Education Papersతెలుగు మీడియం

Topic 12 of 13 · ASD: Identification and Assessment

Differential Assessment

Differential assessment means using tests to decide whether the child's features are really due to ASD or to another condition that looks like autism, and to check whether another condition is present along with ASD. (The differences between the features of autism and intellectual disability were covered in the chapter "Nature, Types and Characteristics"; here we see how to test for them and tell them apart.)

Why differential assessment?

Which condition is separated by which test?

Condition that resembles / occurs with autismAssessment / test that separates itKey sign to look for
Hearing lossHearing screening, audiologist's assessment; ABR / BERA under sedation if neededWhether the lack of response to language is due to hearing loss; newborn screening is not enough
Visual impairmentFunctional vision screening, eye examinationSquint, long-sightedness, short-sightedness
Intellectual disability / global developmental delayCognitive + adaptive behaviour assessmentIf the social and communication deficits match the overall cognitive level, it is not ASD (see the example of a 4-year-old functioning at a 12-month level)
Rett's disorderMECP2 genetic testIf the features resemble Rett's
Fragile X syndromeFragile X DNA probe (FMR1); physical examinationProminent ears, long face, high palate; appears in many different ways in the family
Tuberous sclerosisSkin examination, physical examinationAsh-leaf spots, facial lesions, seizures
Foetal alcohol syndromeHistory + physical examinationMother's history of alcohol use, facial features, growth deficiency
Congenital infections (cytomegalovirus)Prenatal history, physical examinationSmall head, hearing loss appearing later, enlarged liver
Chromosomal disordersHigh-resolution karyotype, FISHMajor chromosomal changes
Landau-Kleffner syndromeSleep EEG / video EEGGradual loss of receptive and expressive language that was present until then
Seizure disorderEEGHistory of seizures, regression
Degenerative neurological disordersUrine organic acids testGradual loss of skills
Metabolic disordersMetabolic screening, amino acid chromatographyCyclic vomiting, protein intolerance
Lead poisoningLead screeningPica
Thyroid problemThyroid testGrowth deficiency
Language disorder / Social (Pragmatic) Communication DisorderLanguage assessment, observationIf restricted, repetitive behaviours are absent, it is not ASD

Steps of differential assessment

  1. History: health, developmental and family history - regression, seizures, genetic conditions in the family.
  2. Physical and neurological examination: physical signs of syndromes, neurological abnormalities.
  3. Sensory testing: ruling out vision and hearing problems early.
  4. Laboratory and genetic tests: only those the history points to.
  5. Direct observation + standard tools: such as ADI-R, ADOS, CARS, ISAA.
  6. Cognitive and adaptive assessment: whether the deficits match the overall level or not.
  7. Team synthesis: the interdisciplinary team together gives the diagnosis and intervention recommendations.
Differential assessment: ruling out look-alike conditions one by one to reach an ASD diagnosis
Differential assessment: ruling out look-alike conditions one by one to reach an ASD diagnosis

Exam focus: Differential assessment = separating ASD from conditions that resemble it. Hearing loss → audiology; intellectual disability → cognitive + adaptive assessment; Rett's → MECP2; Fragile X → FMR1 DNA probe; Landau-Kleffner → sleep EEG. It is ASD only if the deficits do not match the cognitive level.

Memory code: "HIRFL" - Hearing loss (audiology), Intellectual disability (cognitive), Rett's (MECP2), Fragile X (FMR1), Landau-Kleffner (sleep EEG) - the five main look-alikes of autism.

Topic 12 done

Mini exam: 5 questions

Pick an option for each question, then press "Show answers". Your score and the explanations appear at once.

Question 1 / 5

What is 'differential assessment'?

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: (2) Deciding through tests whether the features are due to ASD or to another condition that looks like autism

Differential assessment means deciding through tests whether the child's features are really due to ASD or to another condition that looks like autism, and also checking whether another condition is present along with ASD.

Marks, income and change of school are not differential assessment.

Question 2 / 5

In a child who does not respond to his name, which condition should be ruled out first, and by which assessment?

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: (1) Hearing loss - audiologist's assessment

Not responding to one's name is also seen in hearing loss; so it should be ruled out first with hearing screening and an audiologist's assessment.

Fragile X, Rett's and lead tests are done when there are other signs (physical features, Rett-like features, pica).

Question 3 / 5

Which assessment is mainly needed to separate ASD from intellectual disability?

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: (2) Cognitive and adaptive behaviour assessment

Cognitive and adaptive behaviour assessment is needed to see whether the social and communication deficits match the overall cognitive level; it is ASD only if they do not match.

Vision, allergy and thyroid tests do not show this difference.

Question 4 / 5

Match the following: (1) Fragile X (2) Landau-Kleffner (3) Metabolic disorder (4) Chromosomal disorder - (a) Sleep EEG (b) FMR1 DNA probe (c) High-resolution karyotype (d) Amino acid chromatography

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: (3) 1-b, 2-a, 3-d, 4-c

Fragile X - FMR1 DNA probe (b); Landau-Kleffner - sleep EEG (a); metabolic disorder - amino acid chromatography (d); chromosomal disorder - high-resolution karyotype (c). So 1-b, 2-a, 3-d, 4-c.

The other sets link the tests with the wrong conditions.

Question 5 / 5

If there are only social communication deficits without restricted, repetitive behaviours, which condition is considered in differential assessment?

Answer and explanation

Correct answer: (4) Social (Pragmatic) Communication Disorder

If there are only social communication deficits without restricted, repetitive behaviours, it is not ASD; Social (Pragmatic) Communication Disorder is considered, using language assessment and observation.

Tuberous sclerosis and foetal alcohol syndrome are identified by physical features; Rett's by MECP2.