What is assessment?
Assessment is a process we cannot avoid in daily life. In the family, the classroom, the market, the office or government work - everywhere we assess in order to understand, to adjust and to decide what to do next. In every service, such as health, mental health, guidance and counselling, education, training and employment, "collecting information → analysing it → deciding on improvement" is essential.
- Wallace, Larsen and Elksnin (1992): "Assessment is the process of collecting and analysing information about a person in order to make instructional, administrative and guidance decisions."
- Sundberg and Tyler (1962): Assessment is the process of systematically collecting, organising and analysing information about a person and making decisions about that person on that basis.
This definition has three elements:
- Collection of information
- Analysis of information
- Decision for instruction, administration and guidance
- Assessment and testing are not the same. Testing is only one part of assessment. Besides testing the child directly, assessment includes observing the child in different settings and asking family members.
- Every child is unique; no two are alike. That is why a suitable educational programme is planned for each one on the basis of the assessment results.
Purposes of assessment (why is it needed?)
- Early identification and screening: finding out at an early stage which child in school has special needs. Early identification can prevent an additional disability and stop the problem from growing, and the needed treatment and help can be given in time.
- Decisions on learning strategies and educational placement: deciding the right special education help, teacher and class according to the problem.
- Present level of performance and educational needs: knowing both the child's strengths and weaknesses; planning remedial teaching; a classification decision on which programme to give.
- Designing the IEP: setting goals, preparing the individualised education programme and evaluating it.
- Monitoring: checking understanding during a lesson, watching progress while the programme runs, and judging achievement at the end of training.
Areas to be assessed
- Health, mental ability, speech and language, hearing, vision, motor development, social functioning and academic level.
- Pre-reading, pre-writing and pre-arithmetic skills (the skills needed before reading, writing and arithmetic), and social, motor, cognitive and language skills.
- Information is collected on self-help, social, language, communication, cognitive, motor, academic and vocational aspects from birth to adulthood.
- In special education assessment, details about the child's personal background, academic performance, available resources, family participation in training and voluntary help are also collected.
Types of assessment: formal and informal
| Point | Formal | Informal |
|---|---|---|
| How | Tests, behaviour scales, checklists, interview, questionnaire | Natural interaction between the child and the observer |
| Situation | A well-structured situation | A natural situation |
| Preparation | The tester needs a lot of preparation | Little preparation |
| Benefit | Standard, comparable results | Being natural, it is more likely to bring out the true response |
Norm-Referenced Assessment (NRT)
- This is the traditional method. Information is collected with a tool standardised on a large sample population, and the test-taker's ability is compared with that of others. It is also called formal assessment.
- Every standardised tool has fixed instructions for administration, analysis, interpretation of results and reporting; these must be followed.
- Examples: Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Revised (WISC-R), Illinois Test of Psycholinguistic Abilities (ITPA), Stanford-Binet Intelligence Test, Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test - Revised (PPVT-R), Peabody Individual Achievement Test (PIAT).
Advantages:
- The decision to classify a child as having special needs depends mostly on NRT results.
- The results are easy to explain to parents and to people who know little about tests.
- Most technical information and research are based on them; they are very useful for identifying problems and for screening.
Limitations:
- The information is very general; it is of no direct use for daily classroom teaching. For example, knowing a child's WISC-R score does not tell "what and how to teach"; what matters is whether the child needs to learn the initial consonants, or has difficulty with comprehension.
- Since their main aim is to compare one person with another, they strengthen the idea that "the problem lies in the child". In fact the problem may also lie in the teaching, the placement or the curriculum. NRT does not measure things such as the teacher's behaviour, the content or the sequence.
Criterion-Referenced Assessment (CRT)
- It checks whether the student can perform a skill according to a pre-set standard (criterion). It compares the student with that standard, not with others.
- The skills of a subject are arranged in a hierarchy; what must be learnt first is tested first. For example, in arithmetic, addition comes before multiplication. The next level is taught only after the skill at one level is mastered.
- Indian tools such as MDPS, FACP and BASIC-MR Part A belong to this type.
Advantages:
- The specific skills that need intervention can be identified.
- The next logical skill to teach can be decided; it is of direct use for teaching.
- Formative evaluation is possible: while a skill is being taught, performance is recorded daily / regularly, progress is checked, and one can decide whether the intervention is working, what to teach next, and, if the skill is not mastered, which strategies, methods and materials to change.
Limitations:
- It is hard to fix the passing criterion for a skill. For example, are 90% correct answers enough, or is 100% needed? A wrong criterion makes the student struggle needlessly.
- It is hard to decide which skills to include in the test.
- There is a risk that the skills in the test become the teaching goals; teachers narrow their teaching to what the test measures rather than what is really needed.
Continuous assessment
Assessment is not done once and then dropped; it is a continuous process. The abilities of children with ID are assessed from time to time and the next stage of training is planned.
Assessment → Programme planning → Implementation → Evaluation → Suggested changes → Assessment again
- Evaluation looks at how much the child has achieved against the set criterion after the programme is carried out; it is limited to the programme planned for that child. Assessment also covers other areas that were not planned.
- For example, in a special school for children with intellectual disability, a primary-class student is assessed at admission for programme planning. After a year, when the set period in that class is over, the student is assessed again for administrative and training decisions.
Formative and summative evaluation
- In special education, the same tool can be used for all three: diagnosis, prescription (what to teach) and evaluation.
- Checking understanding during a lesson and checking progress while a programme runs = formative evaluation.
- Checking achievement at the end of a training programme = summative evaluation. It measures how well the key content and skills have been learnt according to the objectives.
- Which tool and which method to use depends on the purpose of the assessment and the kind of information to be collected.
Approaches to assessment
- Clinical assessment
- Psychological assessment
- Educational assessment
- Functional assessment
- Curriculum-based assessment
Exam focus: Assessment = collection + analysis of information + decision (Wallace, Larsen and Elksnin, 1992). NRT = comparison with others, standardised, for screening and classification (WISC-R, Stanford-Binet, ITPA, PPVT-R, PIAT). CRT = comparison with a pre-set criterion, skills in a hierarchy, of direct use for teaching, formative evaluation. During = formative, at the end = summative.
Memory code: "CAD" - assessment = Collect, Analyse, Decide. "Norm = Neighbours, Criterion = Checkpoint" - NRT compares with the people around, CRT with a fixed checkpoint (the criterion).