The debate about what exactly a learning disability is still goes on. Many disciplines meet in this field, so each one sees it differently. It is best seen as a "family or group of disabilities" that affects academic performance and behaviour.
Kirk's Definition (1962-63)
- A learning disability is a retardation, disorder or delayed development in one or more of the processes of speech, language, reading, writing, arithmetic or other school subjects.
- It results from a psychological handicap, caused by a possible dysfunction of the brain (cerebral dysfunction) and/or emotional or behavioural disturbance.
- It is not the result of mental retardation, sensory deprivation, or cultural or instructional factors.
NACHC (1968) / PL 94-142 (1975) / USOE (1977) Definition
The definition given in 1968 under Kirk's chairmanship was adopted almost word for word in PL 94-142 and in the 1977 Federal Register. By the early 1970s it was the most popular definition in the state education departments of the USA. In short:
- A disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using spoken or written language.
- It shows itself as an imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell or do mathematical calculations.
- Included: perceptual handicaps, brain injury, Minimal Brain Dysfunction (MBD), dyslexia and developmental aphasia.
- Not included: learning problems that are mainly the result of visual, hearing or motor disabilities; of mental retardation; of emotional disturbance; or of environmental, cultural or economic disadvantage.
- The 1997 IDEA amendments and IDEA 2004 left this definition almost unchanged. IDEA 1997 wrote it in three parts: (1) the general meaning, (2) the disorders included, (3) the problems not included.
Federal Register (1977): 4 Elements of the Definition
| Element | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Academic difficulties | Difficulties in studies and in mathematical calculations compared with children of the same age |
| Discrepancy between ability and achievement | Achievement not matching intelligence; this is called the aptitude-achievement discrepancy |
| Exclusion of other causes | A problem caused by visual, hearing or speech-language impairment, mental retardation, physical problems, emotional disorder or environmental disadvantage is not LD |
| Neurological dysfunction | The root of the problem is assumed to lie in the working of the central nervous system |
NJCLD Definition (1981, Revised 1988)
The National Joint Committee on Learning Disabilities (NJCLD) is a coalition of parent and professional organisations. It criticised the vague ideas in the PL 94-142 definition and gave a new one:
- Learning disability is a general term. It refers to a heterogeneous group of disorders shown by significant difficulties in the acquisition and use of listening, speaking, reading, writing, reasoning or mathematical abilities.
- These disorders are intrinsic to the individual, are presumed to be due to central nervous system dysfunction, and may occur across the life span.
- Problems in self-regulatory behaviour, social perception and social interaction may exist along with LD, but they do not by themselves make a learning disability.
- LD may occur together with other disabilities (sensory impairment, mental retardation, serious emotional disturbance) or with outside influences (cultural differences, insufficient instruction), but it is not the result of them.
- Here "central nervous system dysfunction" does not mean that the brain is injured; it means that the brain of these children works a little differently from that of other children.
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
Expand "NJCLD".
- (1)National Joint Commission for Learning Disabilities
- (2)National Joint Committee for Language Disabilities
- (3)National Joint Committee for Learning Disabilities
- (4)National Joint Commission for Language Disabilities
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (3) National Joint Committee for Learning Disabilities
The question asks for the full form of NJCLD, the body that gave a widely used definition of learning disabilities.
NJCLD stands for the National Joint Committee on (for) Learning Disabilities. It is a committee in the USA made up of representatives of several organisations working on learning disabilities, which is why it is a 'joint committee'. It defined learning disabilities as a group of disorders shown by significant difficulties in acquiring and using listening, speaking, reading, writing, reasoning or mathematical abilities. So the answer is option (3).
Options (1) and (4) say 'Commission' instead of 'Committee'. Options (2) and (4) say 'Language Disabilities' instead of 'Learning Disabilities'. Remember: C = Committee, LD = Learning Disabilities.
Remember: NJCLD: C = Committee, LD = Learning Disabilities.
ACLD / LDA (1986) and ICLD (1987) Definitions
| Definition | Special feature |
|---|---|
| ACLD / LDA (1986) | Stressed that learning disability is a lifelong, chronic condition; neurological origin; no exclusion clause; spoke of its effect on self-esteem, education, vocation, socialisation and daily living activities (adaptive behaviour) |
| ICLD (1987) | A committee of representatives of US federal agencies; made 2 changes to the NJCLD definition: included deficits in social skills as a type of LD; included Attention Deficit Disorder as a condition that can occur with LD |
| NJCLD revision (1988) | Accepted the "lifelong" point made by the LDA; did not accept the ICLD's "social skills deficit = LD" |
Common Elements in All Definitions
Whichever definition we take, children with a learning disability have these five:
- Intelligence is within the normal range.
- There is a discrepancy between ability and achievement.
- The learning disability is not due to other causes.
- There is difficulty in learning.
- Central nervous system dysfunction is presumed.
DSM and ICD Classifications
- DSM-IV (1994) had 4 types of learning disorders: Reading Disorder, Mathematics Disorder, Disorder of Written Expression, and Learning Disorder Not Otherwise Specified.
- DSM-5 (2013) merged all of them into one Specific Learning Disorder; the area of difficulty (reading, written expression, mathematics) is specified separately.
- ICD-10 groups them as "Specific developmental disorders of scholastic skills" (F81): F81.0 Specific reading disorder (dyslexia), F81.1 Specific spelling disorder, F81.2 Specific disorder of arithmetical skills, F81.3 Mixed disorder.
- According to these classifications, people with a learning disability cannot properly understand what they hear and see, because different parts of the brain do not coordinate well. There are 3 main types: problems in reading, problems in writing and problems in mathematics.
RPwD Act 2016 Definition
- Specific Learning Disabilities is one of the 21 disabilities in the RPwD Act 2016. In the Schedule it is sub-item (a) under the heading "Intellectual Disability" (sub-item (b) = autism).
- Definition: a heterogeneous group of conditions in which there is a deficit in processing language, spoken or written, that may show itself as a difficulty to comprehend, speak, read, write, spell or do mathematical calculations.
- Conditions included: perceptual disabilities, dyslexia, dysgraphia, dyscalculia, dyspraxia and developmental aphasia.
- Benchmark disability = 40% or more.
- Learning disability is not one of the 4 disabilities in the National Trust Act 1999 (autism, cerebral palsy, mental retardation, multiple disabilities).
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
National Trust Act does not cover this disability
- (1)Autism
- (2)Multiple Disabilities
- (3)Cerebral Palsy
- (4)Learning Disabilities
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (4) Learning Disabilities
The question asks which disability is not covered by the National Trust Act 1999.
The National Trust Act 1999 is for the welfare of persons with four disabilities: autism, cerebral palsy, intellectual disability (mental retardation) and multiple disabilities. Such persons may need support throughout life, so the Act provides for things like legal guardianship.
Learning disabilities are not among these four. So the answer is option (4), Learning Disabilities.
Autism (1), multiple disabilities (2) and cerebral palsy (3) are all named in the Act, so none of them is the disability that is left out.
Remember: National Trust covers only four: autism, CP, intellectual disability, multiple disabilities.
Exam focus: NJCLD = National Joint Committee on Learning Disabilities (1981, revised 1988): "general term - heterogeneous group of disorders - central nervous system dysfunction - across the life span". LDA (1986) = lifelong, no exclusion clause. ICLD (1987) = social skills deficit + Attention Deficit Disorder. In the RPwD Act 2016, SLD = perceptual disabilities, dyslexia, dysgraphia, dyscalculia, dyspraxia, developmental aphasia. LD is not in the National Trust Act 1999.
Memory code: The Federal Register's 4 elements are ADEN - Academic difficulty, Discrepancy, Exclusion, Neurological dysfunction. SLD in the RPwD Act is "P + 4 Dys + A" - Perceptual disabilities, Dyslexia, Dysgraphia, Dyscalculia, Dyspraxia, developmental Aphasia. ICLD = "SA": Social skills + Attention deficit.