The nine types of adaptations
These nine types, given by Ebeling, Deschenes and Sprague (1994), are asked in exams with examples:
| Type | What we change | Example |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Input (how instruction is delivered) | The way instruction reaches the learner | Different visual aids, more concrete examples, hands-on activities, cooperative groups; teaching key concepts before the lesson |
| 2. Output (how the learner responds) | The way the learner responds | An oral answer instead of a written one; using a communication book; showing knowledge with hands-on materials |
| 3. Time | Time given for learning, finishing a task or a test | An individual timeline for finishing a task; increasing or decreasing the pace of learning for some learners |
| 4. Difficulty | Skill level, type of problem, rules for doing the work | Allowing a calculator for maths problems; simplifying task directions; changing rules to suit needs |
| 5. Level of support | Increasing personal help for one learner | Peer buddies, teaching assistants, peer tutors, cross-age tutors |
| 6. Size | The number of items to be learnt / completed | Reducing the number of social studies terms to be learnt at a time |
| 7. Degree of participation | How actively the learner takes part in the task | In geography, one learner holds the globe while others point out locations |
| 8. Alternate goals | Changing the goals / expected outcomes while using the same materials | In social studies, one learner locates only the states while others locate the capitals as well |
| 9. Substitute curriculum | Different instruction and different materials for individual goals | One learner learns computer skills while others take a language test (functional curriculum) |
Previous papers questions asked in the exam on what you just read
While teaching social studies, expect one student to be able to locate just the ‘states’ while others learn to locate ‘capitals’ as well is an example for adaptation of
- (1)Alternate goals
- (2)Size
- (3)Level of Support
- (4)Time
Answer & explanation
Correct answer: (1) Alternate goals
The question describes one lesson where one student is expected to locate only the states while the others also locate the capitals, and asks which type of curriculum adaptation this is.
There are nine common types of curriculum adaptation in inclusive classrooms: size, time, level of support, input, difficulty, output, participation, alternate goals and substitute curriculum. In alternate goals, the teacher uses the same lesson and the same materials but changes the expected outcome for a particular student. Here the map and lesson are the same; only the goal differs: ‘states’ for one student, ‘states and capitals’ for the rest. So the answer is option (1). This exact situation is the standard textbook example of alternate goals.
Size (2) means reducing the number of items the learner must learn or complete, for example 10 spelling words instead of 20. Level of support (3) means increasing personal help from a peer, aide or teacher. Time (4) means giving more time to finish a task or test. In this question neither the help nor the time changes, only the goal.
Remember: Same materials, different expected outcome = alternate goals.
- The difference between alternate goals and substitute curriculum: with alternate goals the materials stay the same and only the goal changes. With a substitute curriculum both the materials and the instruction are different. A substitute curriculum is usually used only for children with severe needs.
- Another example of size: reducing theory classes in social studies and increasing practical work.
- Another example of participation: giving the child a globe and asking the child to locate one place after another.
Stages of adaptation and three kinds of adaptation
Janney and Snell (2000) described adaptations in two stages and three kinds:
| Stage | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Stage 1: General adaptations | Adaptations that work like a blueprint for predictable activities and routines |
| Stage 2: Specific adaptations | Adaptations made for a limited period for one particular lesson or activity |
| Kind | What it changes | Sub-types |
|---|---|---|
| Curricular adaptation | What is taught | Supplementary (adding social, communication, study and process skills to the general curriculum); simplified (changing the difficulty level or fewer goals); alternative (functional skills, including social, communication and motor skills) |
| Instructional adaptation | How it is taught and how learning is shown | Instructional stimulus (input) and response (output) - in both: difficulty / quantity, sensory mode (modality), format / materials |
| Ecological adaptation | Where, when and with whom | Who - staff, groups; where - place; when - timetable |
Adaptations to suit learning style
Some learn by seeing, some by hearing, some through imagination, and others through all of these. Teaching with such varied adaptations meets the differences among learners properly. Children with a learning disability should not be given every teaching method at once; use the method each child understands.
| Type of learner | Adaptations |
|---|---|
| Learners who learn by hearing (auditory) | Give tasks in writing as well as by word of mouth; give typed tasks so the learner can read them when needed; offer an oral test instead of a written one; record key information so it can be heard when needed; ask the learner to read aloud (useful for those nearby too); make sure the learner listens carefully to what the teacher says |
| Learners who learn by seeing (visual) | Colourful flash cards; closing the eyes and picturing the information in the mind; showing visual aids related to the lesson; asking the learner to write words, concepts and ideas in notes |
Adaptations in classroom management
- Give small assignments often; short, direct tasks make success possible.
- When the learner has to copy from a book, underline the important points.
- Clear unnecessary objects from where the children sit and keep it tidy.
- Praise at once when the answer is right; give corrective feedback at once when it is wrong.
- Break tasks into very small parts: given 5 problems or 5 sentences at a time, the learner gets them right.
- When the task is hard, the teacher should check in with the learner often for a short while and ask questions; remove distractions.
- Let the learner work in a quiet place with no negative stimuli on the way, so the learner does not get distracted from the work.
- The teacher should seat the learner close by and give feedback at once; keep the learner away from those who disturb.
- Give interest, reinforcement and enough time; when work is given at the right time, the learner understands his or her responsibilities.
- Start with work of short duration and increase the time gradually.
- Have the learner work together with children of the same age.
Exam focus: "One learner locates only states, others locate capitals as well" = alternate goals. "Learning fewer words" = size. "Allowing a calculator" = difficulty. "Holding the globe" = degree of participation. "An oral answer instead of a written one" = output. "Peer tutor" = level of support. Ecological adaptation = where, when and with whom.
Memory code: The nine types are "I-O-T-D-L-S-P-A-S" - "India's Olympic Team Did Lift Some Prizes At Sydney": Input, Output, Time, Difficulty, Level of support, Size, Participation, Alternate goals, Substitute curriculum. "Alternate goals = same materials; substitute curriculum = different materials".